... in which he's chewed through the characters and tropes and stylistic ticks of his entire back catalogue and defecated the digested remains into a slim book that resembles a dog trying unsuccessfully to bite off it's own tail.
I've long been a fan of Auster. Sure, his work can be repetitive, and willfully meaningless, and humorless, and (appropriately) austere. And there's something in the argument that, Joseph Heller-like, his best work will always be his first, the intricately layered triptych of New York Trilogy. But for me he's one of the most important American novelists of the past twenty years. Works such as the aforementioned NYT, The Music Of Chance, and The Book Of Illusions represent some of the best examples of experimental fiction to have achieved mainstream notoriety. His style of hauling Camus into agreeable Americana, of offering dense philosophy in eminently readable prose and page-turning plots, is rarely bettered.
But Auster's latest is a mess. And what a mess. I'm only halfway through Tales of the Scriptorium, a slight and sorry-looking tome in it's bleak dust jacket, but it's making me reconsider whether he was any good in the first place.
By reintroducing characters and leitmotifs from his previous novels, and offering them up as vague dream-like apparitions to the all too familiar character of the confused old man sitting in a windowless room with no idea why he got there, Auster is asking many of his usual questions - about the relationship between truth and fiction, between a writer and his characters, between fate and random occurrence - the only difference this time is that all these worthy themes have been denuded of interest. Auster himself seems bored; the prose is tacky and laden with heavy adjectives, and his trick of making pages fly by seemingly untethered is conspicuous by its absence.
Like I said, I'm only halfway through, but I don't think things are likely to improve. My only hope is that this is some kind of line in the sand for Auster; that he's drawing a close on all these characters and themes, and his next project will have a freshness reflective of the mental clearing-house that Scriptorium represents. It almost feels like a book tossed-off to fulfill a contract, with no real interest or input from the author, much like a band releasing a half-hearted album simply to get rid of the label. Hopefully Auster is something of a Lou Reed, and Scriptorium is his own personal Metal Machine Music.